| Year | Winner | Runner-Up | Venue |
| 1895 | Horace Rawlins | Willie Dunn | Newport Golf Club, Newport, RI |
| 1896 | James Foulis | Horace Rawlins | Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Southampton, NY |
| 1897 | Joe Lloyd | Willie Anderson | Chicago Golf Club, Wheaton, IL |
| 1898 | Fred Herd | Alex Smith | Myopia Hunt Club, Hamilton, MA |
| 1899 | Willie Smith | George Low, Val Fitzjohn, W.H. Way | Baltimore Country Club, Baltimore |
| 1900 | Harry Vardon | John H. Taylor | Chicago Golf Club, Wheaton, IL |
| 1901 | Willie Anderson | Alex Smith | Myopia Hunt Club, Hamilton, MA |
| 1902 | Laurie Auchterlonie | Stewart Gardner | Garden City Golf Club, Garden City, NY |
| 1903 | Willie Anderson | David Brown | Baltusrol Golf Club, Springfield, NJ |
| 1904 | Willie Anderson | Gil Nicholls | Glen View Club, Golf, IL |
| 1905 | Willie Anderson | Alex Smith | Myopia Hunt Club, Hamilton, MA |
| 1906 | Alex Smith | Willie Smith | Onwentsia Club, Lake Forest, IL |
| 1907 | Alex Ross | Gil Nicholls | Philadelphia Cricket Club, Chestnut Hill, PA |
| 1908 | Fred McLeod | Willie Smith | Myopia Hunt Club, Hamilton, MA |
| 1909 | George Sargent | Tom McNamara | Englewood Golf Club, Englewood, NJ |
| 1910 | Alex Smith | John McDermott, Macdonald Smith | Philadelphia Cricket Club, Chestnut Hill, PA |
| 1911 | John McDermott | Mike Brady, George Simpson | Chicago Golf Club, Wheaton, IL |
| 1912 | John McDermott | Tom McNamara | CC of Buffalo, Buffalo |
| 1913 | Francis Ouimet | Harry Vardon, Edward Ray | The Country Club, Brookline, MA |
| 1914 | Walter Hagen | Chick Evans | Midlothian Country Club, Blue Island, IL |
| 1915 | Jerry Travers | Tom McNamara | Baltusrol GC, Springfield, NJ |
| 1916 | Chick Evans | Jock Hutchison | Minikahda Club, Minneapolis |
| 1917 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1918 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1919 | Walter Hagen | Mike Brady | Brae Burn Country Club, West Newton, MA |
| 1920 | Edward Ray | Harry Vardon, Jack Burke, Leo Diegel, Jock Hutchison | Inverness Country Club, Toledo |
| 1921 | Jim Barnes | Walter Hagen, Fred McLeod | Columbia Country Club, Chevy Chase, MD |
| 1922 | Gene Sarazen | John L. Black, Bobby Jones | Skokie Country Club, Glencoe, IL |
| 1923 | Bobby Jones | Bobby Cruickshank | Inwood Country Club, Inwood, NY |
| 1924 | Cyril Walker | Bobby Jones | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1925 | W. MacFarlane | Bobby Jones | Worcester Country Club, Worcester, MA |
| 1926 | Bobby Jones | Joe Turnesa | Scioto Country Club, Columbus, OH |
| 1927 | Tommy Armour | Harry Cooper | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1928 | Johnny Farrell | Bobby Jones | Olympia Fields Country Club, Matteson, IL |
| 1929 | Bobby Jones | Al Espinosa | Winged Foot GC, Mamaroneck, NY |
| 1930 | Bobby Jones | Macdonald Smith | Interlachen Country Club, Hopkins, MN |
| 1931 | Billy Burke | George Von Elm | Inverness Country Club, Toledo |
| 1932 | Gene Sarazen | Phil Perkins, Bobby Cruickshank | Fresh Meadows Country Club, Flushing, NY |
| 1933 | Johnny Goodman | Ralph Guldahl | North Shore Country Club, Glenview, IL |
| 1934 | Olin Dutra | Gene Sarazen | Merion Cricket Club, Ardmore, PA |
| 1935 | Sam Parks Jr. | Jimmy Thompson | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1936 | Tony Manero | Harry Cooper | Baltusrol Golf Club (Upper Course), Springfield, NJ |
| 1937 | Ralph Guldahl | Sam Snead | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1938 | Ralph Guldahl | Dick Metz | Cherry Hills Country Club, Denver |
| 1939 | Byron Nelson | Craig Wood, Denny Shute | Philadelphia CC, Chestnut Hill, PA |
| 1940 | Lawson Little | Gene Sarazen | Canterbury Golf Club, Cleveland |
| 1941 | Craig Wood | Denny Shute | Colonial Club, Fort Worth |
| 1942 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1943 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1944 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1945 | No Tournament | No Tournament | No Tournament |
| 1946 | Lloyd Mangrum | Vic Ghezzi, Byron Nelson | Canterbury Golf Club, Cleveland |
| 1947 | Lew Worsham | Sam Snead | St. Louis Country Club, Clayton, MO |
| 1948 | Ben Hogan | Jimmy Demaret | Riviera Country Club, Los Angeles |
| 1949 | Cary Middlecoff | Sam Snead, Clayton Heafner | Medinah Country Club, Medinah, IL |
| 1950 | Ben Hogan | Lloyd Mangrum, George Fazio | Merion Golf Club, Ardmore, PA |
| 1951 | Ben Hogan | Clayton Heafner | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1952 | Julius Boros | Ed Oliver | Northwood Country Club, Dallas |
| 1953 | Ben Hogan | Sam Snead | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1954 | Ed Furgol | Gene Littler | Baltusrol GC (Lower Course), Springfield, NJ |
| 1955 | Jack Fleck | Ben Hogan | Olympic Club (Lake Course), San Francisco |
| 1956 | Cary Middlecoff | Ben Hogan, Julius Boros | Oak Hill Country Club, Rochester, NY |
| 1957 | Dick Mayer | Cary Middlecoff | Inverness Club, Toledo |
| 1958 | Tommy Bolt | Gary Player | Southern Hills Country Club, Tulsa |
| 1959 | Billy Casper | Bob Rosburg | Winged Foot GC, Mamaroneck, NY |
| 1960 | Arnold Palmer | Jack Nicklaus | Cherry Hills Country Club, Denver |
| 1961 | Gene Littler | Bob Goalby, Doug Sanders | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1962 | Jack Nicklaus | Arnold Palmer | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1963 | Julius Boros | Jacky Cupit, Arnold Palmer | The Country Club, Brookline, MA |
| 1964 | Ken Venturi | Tommy Jacobs | Congressional Country Club, Bethesda, MD |
| 1965 | Gary Player | Kel Nagle | Bellerive Country Club, St. Louis |
| 1966 | Billy Casper | Arnold Palmer | Olympic Club (Lake Course), San Francisco |
| 1967 | Jack Nicklaus | Arnold Palmer | Baltusrol GC (Lower Course), Springfield, NJ |
| 1968 | Lee Trevino | Jack Nicklaus | Oak Hill Country Club, Rochester, NY |
| 1969 | Orville Moody | Deane Beman, Al Geiberger, Bob Rosburg | Champions GC (Cypress Creek Course), Houston |
| 1970 | Tony Jacklin | Dave Hill | Hazeltine Golf Club, Chaska, MN |
| 1971 | Lee Trevino | Jack Nicklaus | Merion Golf Club (East Course), Ardmore, PA |
| 1972 | Jack Nicklaus | Bruce Crampton | Pebble Beach GL, Pebble Beach, CA |
| 1973 | Johnny Miller | John Schlee | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1974 | Hale Irwin | Forrest Fezler | Winged Foot GC, Mamaroneck, NY |
| 1975 | Lou Graham | John Mahaffey | Medinah Country Club, Medinah, IL |
| 1976 | Jerry Pate | Tom Weiskopf, Al Geiberger | Atlanta Athletic Club, Duluth, GA |
| 1977 | Hubert Green | Lou Graham | Southern Hills Country Club, Tulsa |
| 1978 | Andy North | Dave Stockton, J.C. Snead | Cherry Hills Country Club, Denver |
| 1979 | Hale Irwin | Gary Player, Jerry Pate | Inverness Club, Toledo |
| 1980 | Jack Nicklaus | Isao Aoki | Baltusrol GC (Lower Course), Springfield, NJ |
| 1981 | David Graham | George Burns, Bill Rogers | Merion Golf Club, Ardmore, PA |
| 1982 | Tom Watson | Jack Nicklaus | Pebble Beach GL, Pebble Beach, CA |
| 1983 | Larry Nelson | Tom Watson | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1984 | Fuzzy Zoeller | Greg Norman | Winged Foot GC, Mamaroneck, NY |
| 1985 | Andy North | Dave Barr, T.C. Chen, Denis Watson | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1986 | Ray Floyd | Lanny Wadkins, Chip Beck | Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Southampton, NY |
| 1987 | Scott Simpson | Tom Watson | Olympic Club (Lake Course), San Francisco |
| 1988 | Curtis Strange | Nick Faldo | The Country Club, Brookline, MA |
| 1989 | Curtis Strange | Chip Beck, Mark McCumber, Ian Woosnam | Oak Hill Country Club, Rochester, NY |
| 1990 | Hale Irwin | Mike Donald | Medinah Country Club, Medinah, IL |
| 1991 | Payne Stewart | Scott Simpson | Hazeltine Golf Club, Chaska, MN |
| 1992 | Tom Kite | Jeff Sluman | Pebble Beach GL, Pebble Beach, CA |
| 1993 | Lee Janzen | Pyne Stewart | Baltusrol GC, Springfield, NJ |
| 1994 | Ernie Els | Loren Roberts, Colin Montgomerie | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 1995 | Corey Pavin | Greg Norman | Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Southampton, NY |
| 1996 | Steve Jones | Davis Love III, Tom Lehman | Oakland Hills Country Club, Birmingham, MI |
| 1997 | Ernie Els | Colin Montgomerie | Congressional Country Club, Bethesda, MD |
| 1998 | Lee Janzen | Payne Stewart | The Olympic Club, San Francisco |
| 1999 | Payne Stewart | Phil Mickelson | Pinehurst Resort and CC, Pinehurst, NC |
| 2000 | Tiger Woods | Miguel Angel Jimenez, Ernie Els | Pebble Beach GL, Pebble Beach, CA |
| 2001 | Retief Goosen | Mark Brooks | Southern Hills Country Club, Tulsa |
| 2002 | Tiger Woods | Phil Mickelson | Bethpage Black Course, Bethpage, NY |
| 2003 | Jim Furyk | Stephen Leaney | Olympia Fields Country Club, Olympia Fields, IL |
| 2004 | Retief Goosen | Phil Mickelson | Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, Southampton, NY |
| 2005 | Michael Campbell | Tiger Woods | Pinehurst Resort & CC, Pinehurst, N.C. |
| 2006 | Geoff Ogilvy | Jim Furyk, Colin Montgomerie, Phil Mickelson | Winged Foot Golf Club, Mamaroneck, New York |
| 2007 | Angel Cabrera | Jim Furyk, Tiger Woods | Oakmont Country Club, Oakmont, PA |
| 2008 | Tiger Woods | Rocco Mediate | Torrey Pines (South Course), La Jolla, CA |